Coniglio's Old Fashioned
Pizza
"~200 pizzas a day. 2023 NJ Pizza Bowl winner. Cash only."
South Street · $$ · Mexican
"Bold Mexican-American with strong daily-flavor frozen margs. The comps alone are worth the trip."
Quick Facts
Hours
Shrimp Tacos
"Purple cabbage slaw, creamy sauce with range. The default order."
Plantain Shrimp Guacamole Bites
"Off-menu comp — if they ever put this on the menu, order it immediately."
Blueberry Frozen Margarita
"Daily flavors now. Bright, strong, not a slushee."
The frozen margaritas are doing daily flavors now and that alone is worth the walk downtown. Family dinner on a Saturday — blueberry frozen margs to start, shrimp tacos on purple cabbage slaw, and a comp of plantain shrimp guacamole bites that aren’t on the menu but should be. Paper menus are back. More energy in the room than last time. Come on a Friday or Saturday.
Pizza
"~200 pizzas a day. 2023 NJ Pizza Bowl winner. Cash only."
Italian
"Opened December 2025. Ex-Michelin chef Jordan Petriello. Handmade pasta with imported Italian flour, house-churned gelato. BYOB. The most significant opening South Street has seen in years."
Bakery Pastry · Cafe Coffee
"Central Asian pastry on South Street. The Honey Cake is why people line up. Handcrafted daily, European and Central Asian traditions."